check
Real Problem of Disagreement, The | The Federmann Center for the Study of Rationality

Real Problem of Disagreement, The

Citation:

Konigsberg, Amir . “Real Problem Of Disagreement, The”. Discussion Papers 2012. Web.

Abstract:

The problem of disagreement asks about the appropriate response (typically the response of a peer) upon encountering a disagreement between peers. The responses proposed in the literature offer different solutions to the problem, each of which has more or less normative appeal. Yet none of these seems to engage with what seems to be the real problem of disagreement. It is my aim in this paper to highlight what I think the real problem of disagreement is. It is, roughly, the problem of deciding whether a revisionary tactic is appropriate following the discovery of disagreement as well as deciding which revisionary tactic is appropriate. This, I will show, is a slippery and inevitable problem that any discussion of disagreement ought to deal with.

Website